Customer Reviews
Average Customer Review
(31 customer reviews) 38 of 41 people found the following review helpful
Overwhelming Details,
July 24, 2000 "rukmini" - See all my reviews
This review is from: Molecular Cell Biology (Hardcover)
As a reference book, this book is handy to have. As a primary textbook for the classroom, this book is impossible. Each subsection of each chapter is overwhelmed with details of a process as it pertains to a variety of model systems. With the increasing amount of information on molecular biology available to us, it becomes vital that authors are able to extract key concepts, present them clearly, and then support them with detailed examples. The authors of this book instead have presented page after page of details, leaving the reader to wonder exactly what it was they were supposed to glean from the forgoing monolith. I found Albert's text to be far superior in readability and organization.
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful
A must-have!,
May 6, 2000 Math PC (Pasadena, CA, USA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Molecular Cell Biology (Hardcover)
This book is an essential tool for both students and professionals that need to broaden their knowledge in molecular cell biology. It provides the fundamental concepts and contains high quality illustrations/graphics. The CD-ROM is also a valuable tool that one can have as it contains basically the book itself.
33 of 39 people found the following review helpful
Rehash of previous edition to prevent resale.,
January 25, 2005 art chetype - See all my reviews
This review is from: Molecular Cell Biology (Hardcover)
The book matches PERFECTLY to the previous edition... with loads of cut and paste of partial paragraphs. The result is that you could never find your way through a class using this edition with the previous edition: curbs the used book market. There is nothing more. No 'cutting edge technology' and minimal new info... not worth a new edition. All the "hard work" of putting together this edition was NOT done by the Authors, but by "hardworking" editors: NOT scientists. It isn't presenting any new science worthy of a new edition... thats just an appeal.
The editing may have taken a lot of work but they obviously had a deadline! The combinations of sentences formed for the new edition from sentences edited from this and that chapter of the old edition are grammatical nightmares!
The illustrations are also second rate.
Why this book is popular must be a source of wonder to the editors. Half baked edition with undeserved popularity.
Worse,...Read more